SEO Agency NYC

Comparing Bing Webmaster tools vs Google Search Console (GSC)

Bing, the often misaligned search engine, has a pretty comprehensive Webmaster Tools suite – feature matching Google’s Search Console almost 1:1 while also having some pretty cool free SEO tools that could benefit SEOs and Web Admins outside of just Bing (we’ll post about that later). We’ll follow this up with a post on what free SEO tools that Bing Webmaster Tools provides that Google doesn’t and how these tools work in individual posts later.

David vs Goliath?

Many webmasters and SEOs are probably quick to dismiss Bing Webmaster Tools (which is Bing’s version of Google Search Console or GSC). Probably a little too quick. We all know that Google is the behemoth of Search, especially outside of Russia, China, and Brazil. And Bing is probably the biggest bastion against Google being a complete and outright monopoly. Bing’s percentage share varies wildly between claims, stats, and topics. Bing is, however, very popular among Microsft brand loyalists – especially the folks who work in IT across Microsoft products like Exchange, ASP, Azure, Windows, etc.

For the most part, search engine webmaster tools allow webmasters to see how search engines are crawling, assessing, indexing, and sending traffic to their sites. For the most part, these are search engine-specific, especially crawl, index, and search data. GSC won’t show you data from Yandex or DuckDuckGo but Analytics will. However, GSC will tell you where it’s found canonical issues, or cannot index a page, if there are errors on the page or if it found your page and just hasn’t deemed it worthy of indexing yet (there are two reports for this function: Crawled, not yet indexed and Discovered, not yet indexed.)

Mirror, Mirror on the wall

Bing provides many of the same features that GSC does, plus a couple of extra features that GSC doesn’t and are really valuable inside and outside of just Bing. In fact, some of these are amongst the best and I really have to give the Bing Webmaster team a hat tip on building quite a great product.

To see what Bing does better, read our blog post on Bing’s free SEO tools (that Google doesn’t do).

Firstly, Domain and Website Authentication

With setting up any tool, comes the hassle of creating an account. While you can use one Google account for Analytics, GSC, Ads, Tag Manager, Data Studio, etc – you often have to go through different validation exercises for different tools. For example, for Analytics and GSC (although if you have enough permissions in Analytics, this will give you auto-access in GSC) but Data Studio requires separate authentication for both. As does SEMrush, also needs to be validated for Google Data Studio and then for GA and GSC separately again.

Bing Webmaster Validation import from GSC

Bing lets you import your GSC properties – so if you’ve already done this, there’s no more extra work, just import it and give it a few days to update its data!

Familiar Interface and Search Tool Functionality

Bing Webmaster Tools Menu

Bing has copied lots and lots of features from Google over the years. I’ve been using Microsoft search since well before Bing was launched. From maps to video, news, image search, and how results are displayed – its a mini-clone. And Google doesn’t have a lot of legal lee-way to move here – lest it risks more anti-trust cases.

And so, Bing’s webmaster tools interface is no different. Google Search Console URL Inspection Tool results:

And this is Google’s well-known URL Inspection interface:

 

What basic and comparable features does Bing provide?

 

Bing Webmaster Tools Description Google Search Console Who has the Better Tool?
Search Performance Keywords, Impressions, CTR and Pages

Google Seach Performance works pretty much the same way

URL Inspection See if a URL can be crawled, has been crawled, can be indexed and when or whether it can or can’t be indexed (or crawled)
Sitemaps Add Sitemaps, see when they were last crawled, and compare the Index rate
URL Submission Submit up to 10k URLs per day from your domain

Via URL Inspection – “Request Indexing” but typically limited to 25 per day per account (user)

Bing
SEO  A set of tools that Bind provides including its secret weapon: SEO Scan ~ Bing
Block URLs This tool allows you to quickly block a URL – faster than using NOINDEX (which Bing still recommends doing). 

Via Removal Requests, but it takes 24 hours and the page must be blocked

Bing
SEO – Keyword Research Provides related keyword phrases and volumes for Keyword Research Similar to GSC but isn’t limited to your site. Similar to Google Ads but impressions seem much more accurate Bing
Microsoft Clarity Like Optimize Available in Google Optimize Bing

Does Bing Webmaster Tools do anything better than Google Search Console?

There are some things Bing does a little better though. For one, it indexes new content very quickly, even without its “IndexNow” WP plugin. Here’s a list of things Bing does better – but please take note, these are Microsoft Bing specific:

  1. Block URL 
  2. URL Submission
  3. Keyword Research

Block URL

Bing is just faster and doesn’t require a 404, 301, or NOINDEX tag to take effect. Google should really take notes and keep up here. Not every webmaster, website owner, web team, or marketing team member has access to their website to take down pages or mark them with NOINDEX (or both). So in most cases, this means asking their internal or external web team, which means waiting for approval, and time, and potentially incurring extra costs. But mostly, waiting. This makes the Google tool far from ideal. 

Deleting a page doesn’t automatically remove it from the Search engine index OR its cache (which is built to accommodate mistakes and as an aid to webmasters who might have accidentally had a page unpublished or deleted by accident). Google’s Removal tool also can take 24 hours to take effect. So while the page is no longer live on your site, the contents could be live in the search results for hours/months (if nothing is done). If the contents are embarrassing or subject to a legal issue – hours can be a long time. Read the Bing Documentation here: Block URLs – Bing Webmaster Tools

URL Submission

Google seems a bit stingy with its ~25 URLs per day limit and many Webmasters complaining of days to work – but this is really down to authority. If you have enough Authority, Google would be auto-indexing within seconds.

Keyword Research

Google has a very powerful, but hidden Keyword research component in its performance tool but this is limited to what your site ranks for or has been considered for to be indexed. So, if you haven’t adequately covered or even mentioned a topic, you’re not going to get any data.

Bing Keyword Research

Bing separates this keyword data  into:

  • Related Keywords
  • Questions Keywords (like SEMrush)
  • Newly Discovered (very useful for blogging)

It also gives a breakdown by Country and global searches, 

And it lets you filter by country, language and device

Read the Bing Webmaster Tools documentation here: Keyword Research Documentation

More Posts

Thoughts on hiring an SEO Expert

This is a question that comes up frequently – in meetings, at events, and on online forums, like Reddit. I’ve written this answer a hundred

SEO friendly CMS

Best SEO-Friendly CMS: A Primer

Background It makes me sad when I see how agencies claim to be digital-first and SEO friendly and then…..The simplistic non-effort these agencies put into